Forest Governance, Law Enforcement Under Job Creation Law

Regardless of some fundamental weaknesses, the Job Creation Law opens up the chance for administration law enforcement in the management of natural resources.

While it is true that the Job Creation Law contains some fundamental weaknesses, it also opens up the chance for enforcement of the administration law of natural resources in Indonesia. This account was exposed in the webinar Bincang Hukum #5 with the subject of Forestry Sector Governance and Law Enforcement Under the Job Creation Law on 14 July 2021.

Moderated by Timer Manurung and streamed on YouTube, the webinar was held by Auriga Nusantara. Joining as speakers were Yazid Nurhuda (the Director for Criminal Law Enforcement of the Directorate General of Law Enforcement at the Ministry of Environment and Forestry), Hariadi Kartodihardjo (professor of forestry at the IPB), Boy Jerry Even Sembiring (Policy Studies Manager of the Indonesian Forum for Living Environment or Walhi), and Roni Saputra (the Director of Law Enforcement of Auriga).

In his presentation, Yazid disclosed that in the era before the Job Creation Law, the focus of law enforcement were ultimum remedium (criminal law as the last resort of law enforcement) and restorative justice (putting forward the integral approach to the perpetrator as well as the victim, including the environment, to look for the solution). The Job Creation Law, he said, emphasizes primum remedium instead, that is criminal law as the sole measure in law enforcement. With primum remedium, he added, even administrative offenses are subject to sanctions.

Yazid offered the example of how the Job Creation Law subjects law offenses by palm plantations that don’t have business licences to more distinct and rigid sanctions. According to Article 102B, such corporations that have developed palm plantations before the enactment of the Job Creation Law will be fined. The companies will then be given the right to do business in line with the previous function of the forest in the area. If the area is a production forest, after the payment of the imposed fine, the companies will be discharged from the forest. If the companies were in protection forest, the will be granted with the approval of forest use after the payment of the fine (meaning they are not discharged from the area). Meanwhile, if the area is a conservation forest, after the payment of the fine, the companies will be directed to become conservation partners.

Roni Saputra, however, conveyed that the Job Creation Law precisely removed some penal regulations, like the elimination of Article 102 of the Environmental Protection and Management Law that regulates criminal sanction against unlawful waste management. Other than that, Article 82B of the Job Creation Law entirely cripples the provision of Article 99 of the Environmental Protection and Management Law, whereas in fact it is in this article that law enforcement agencies are mostly based on their efforts to bring in responsible corporations in the forest and land fires cases.

Additionally, Roni revealed that the Job Creation Law also withdrew some provisions concerning prohibition norms in the Forestry Law, such as prohibition of cutting down trees in an indiscriminate manner and ban of entering the forest arbitrarily; prohibition of forest exploitation; and prohibition of transporting, occupying, and owning forest products without legal documents that is stipulated in Article 50 of the Forestry Law.

Roni deemed the shift of penal sanction norms to administrative sanctions a setback in environmental protection, because it places law enforcement in the hands of the government (to be precise, the executive), rather than judicative, hence opening up to corruption.

Prof. Hariadi noted that the Job Creation Law doesn’t offer answers as to how the corruption eradication efforts in the forestry sector can be carried on, including those led by the Corruption Eradication Commission since 2010, one of which in the form of the National Movement to Save Natural Resources. Furthermore, using corruption risk assessment methodology, he counted the potentiality of corruption in the Job Creation Law and its implementing regulations in the forestry sector, particularly Government Regulation No. 23 of 2021 on Forestry.

The presentation by Prof. Hariadi reminded of the state capture corruption content in the Job Creation Law and its implementing regulations. State capture corruption is the potentiality of or corruption opportunities that are precisely opened up by regulations, policies, institutionalization, budget allocation, and even formal procedures. This is especially concerning because, according Prof. Hariadi, the Law lacks transparency in public information.

Walhi, as expressed in Boy’s presentation, also considered the Job Creation Law likely to be a threat to the people’s sovereignty in forestry management. This will be the case because the Law provides more room exclusively for corporate investment, even though the reality, in practice, has been exposing inequality in the forestry management.

In Auriga’s documentation, as much as 93,2 percent of forest utilization permits have been granted to corporations in the form of forest concession rights (HPH), industrial plantation concessions (HTI), borrow to use permits, and forest release permits for palm plantations. Only 6,8 percent (up to 2,8 million hectares) of the forest utilization permits that have been given to local people in the form of customary forest, community forest, village forest, and community plantation forest.

 

In order to keep maximizing the opportunities contained in the text and context of the Job Creation Law, Prof. Hariadi recommended the filing of a judicial review of the Law to the Constitutional Court, especially in relation to its provisions in the forestry sector.

 

Speakers and presentations

Yazid Nurhuda (the Director for Criminal Law Enforcement of the Directorate General of Law Enforcement at the Ministry of Environment and Forestry): The Shift of Law Enforcement Norms in the Forestry Sector

Hariadi Kartodihardjo (professor of forestry at IPB University): The Consequences of the Job Creation Law in the Management of Natural Resources of the Forestry Sector

Boy Jerry Even Sembiring (Policy Studies Manager of the Indonesian Forum for Living Environment or Walhi): Who Owns the Sovereignty of Forest Management?

Roni Saputra (the Director of Law Enforcement of Auriga): Law Enforcement Under the Job Creation Law
 

Time and place

Date: Wednesday, 14 July 2021

Time: 13:00-15:35

Place: Auriga Nusantara YouTube channel